Studies on obedience to authority: the Milgram experiment
The classic experiment
In 1961 an experiment was conducted by Stanley Milgram, a psychologist at Yale University who was interested in understanding the mechanisms underlying events on the scale of the Final Solution. The son of Jews who had fled Nazi persecution, Milgram was interested in demonstrating that dispositional characteristics of the Germans as a people, and their educational system, were responsible for the horrors of which the Second World War was the backdrop, and that in the United States a “Final Solution” could never have taken place.

In the experiment, the subjects had answered an advertisement for a study on memory and learning and, on arrival, met another subject (in reality a confederate of the researchers) with whom they had the chance to socialise. The roles of teacher and learner were then drawn “at random”. The real subject was invariably given the role of teacher. He was then led to a separate room. Into this other room the fake subject was led and strapped to a chair with fake electrodes around his wrists. The subject watched as the researcher bound the learner’s wrists with sturdy straps “to avoid excessive movement during the experiment”, and as the electrodes were fixed firmly to the wrists to avoid “any burns or blisters”. The subject had in front of him a menacing-looking “machine” consisting of thirty switches, corresponding to “electric shocks” increasing by 15 volts per switch. It went from the first switch, marked “15”, to the last, “450” volts. Below, a brief description of the effect of the shocks was also given, ranging from “SLIGHT SHOCK” under 15 volts to “DANGER SEVERE SHOCK” around 375 volts, to an eloquent “X X X” under 450 volts. In some experiments the subject was allowed to feel a sample of what a low-voltage shock would be like. In the role of teacher, the subject was to teach the other participant, in the role of learner, a list of word pairs and then test him; whenever the learner made a mistake, the teacher was to administer a shock of ever-increasing intensity because, so he was told, the experiment aimed to assess the effects of punishment on learning.
After each word the learner could give one of four possible answers, by pressing one of four buttons which lit a corresponding light in front of the subjects.
At first the learner made no mistakes, but as the questions became harder he began to make them, and each mistake was followed by an electric shock. To each of them the learner responded with a cry of pain that grew more intense as the shocks increased, until the learner shouted to be released, or that he had heart problems, or that he felt ill.
The subject asked a researcher sitting behind him what he should do. The researcher urged him on with a series of sentences already laid down by Milgram: “please continue”; “the experiment requires that you continue”; “it is absolutely essential that you continue”; if the subject asked who would take responsibility should the learner suffer permanent damage to his health, the researcher replied that he took full responsibility.
The shocks administered were fake and the learner was an actor paid to scream every time they were “administered”; after 200 volts the actor was to protest, saying he wanted to be released, and at around 300 volts the actor was to fall silent, pretending to have fainted. The experiment consisted in seeing how many shocks the subject would inflict before stopping.
Before the experiment Milgram asked the psychology graduate students at Yale University how many people, in their view, would administer shocks up to the maximum intensity (450 volts). They estimated about 1% of the population. A similar prediction was made by a group of middle-class people and by a group of psychiatrists who were asked for an estimate.
The results of the experiment were quite different.
On average the highest shock given was 360 volts, and 62.5% of the subjects administered the maximum. 80% of the subjects went on giving shocks even after the learner, who had earlier mentioned his heart condition, screamed to be released.
In that situation one observes in the subjects an inner conflict analogous to that experienced by the men of the Battalion in the Józefów action; Milgram himself reports: “I observed a mature and initially poised businessman enter the laboratory smiling and confident. Within 20 minutes he was reduced to a twitching, stuttering wreck, who was rapidly approaching a point of nervous collapse. He constantly pulled on his earlobe, and twisted his hands. At one point he pushed his fist into his forehead and muttered: ‘Oh God, let’s stop it.’ And yet he continued to respond to every word of the experimenter, and obeyed to the end.”
For Milgram, then, obedience to authority would be a product of socialisation and evolution, “a deeply ingrained behaviour tendency” to carry out actions, even repugnant ones in violation of “universally accepted” moral norms, in response to the directives of authority. It therefore seems clear that refusing to obey the normative pressure represented by a researcher who, with his white coat, his uniform, embodies scientific authority, is extremely difficult.
The variants
Milgram’s experiment was repeated many times and in various countries around the world; several variants of it have also been conducted, at least 16 different ones by Milgram alone, some of which will be examined here.
In all the variants examined here, we see a rapid drop in obedience to the normative pressure exerted by the researcher.
In one variant there was not one teacher but two. The subject’s task was to administer the shocks, the second “teacher’s” to ask the questions. The second teacher was also a confederate of the researcher. At a certain point in the experiment this second teacher would refuse to continue despite the experimenter’s command. The disobedience of his “colleague” made it much easier for the subject to refuse to go on; in this case only 10% of subjects reached 450 volts.
In another variant, about 20% of subjects administer the highest shocks when the researcher leaves the room and the second “teacher” gives the order to proceed instead.
In yet another variant, fewer than 1% reach the highest shocks when the subject can choose for himself which shock to administer.
Far from refuting Milgram’s thesis, these variants seem to reinforce it. The moment authority is absent or openly challenged, the powerful modification of behaviour it induces also disappears.

Studies on role: the Stanford prison experiment
In 1971 Philip Zimbardo conducted an experiment at Stanford University that would later become known as the Stanford prison experiment.
First Zimbardo and his colleagues gave diagnostic tests to a group of 70 volunteers who had answered an advertisement; of these, 24 subjects, all young males, were selected for their maturity, emotional stability and normality. All were students at American or Canadian colleges, of middle-class background and with no criminal record.
The only motivation for these students to take part in the experiment was the high pay, 15 dollars a day (a lot of money in 1971), for a total experiment duration of two weeks.
The subjects were assigned by lot to the roles of “guards” and “prisoners”. The prisoners were to remain locked in a “prison” (in reality a basement belonging to Stanford) set up for the purpose for the whole duration of the experiment, while the “guards” were to make sure the prisoners did not escape and that order was maintained. The guards worked in groups of three in eight-hour shifts; when not working they could return to their daily lives, which was not the case for the prisoners, who were immersed in the prison reality the whole time.
The guards had to make rules to maintain order and could make new ones as needed, should the situation require it.
At the start of the experiment an arrest was simulated, along with the whole series of ritual procedures that normally follow it. First the guards surprised the prisoners by turning up in broad daylight at their homes, where they were publicly handcuffed and taken to a collection point; they were then fingerprinted, stripped, subjected to hygiene and delousing procedures, and put into a uniform.
They were then blindfolded and taken to the prison, where they received a number that would be their name for the rest of the experiment, and were put in a very small cell together with two other prisoners.
Zimbardo immediately noticed dramatic changes in every aspect of their behaviour, thinking and feeling. Zimbardo himself was surprised by the extent of the changes: “In less than a week the experience of imprisonment undid (temporarily) a lifetime of learning, […] and the ugliest, most base, pathological side of human nature surfaced. We were horrified because we saw some boys (the guards) treat others as if they were despicable animals, taking pleasure in cruelty, while other boys (the prisoners) became servile, dehumanised robots who thought only of escape, of their own individual survival, and of their mounting hatred for the guards.”
In the first four days, three of the prisoners had to be released because they showed, among other symptoms, hysterical crying, mental confusion and severe depression.
Any sense of solidarity the prisoners felt for one another was systematically demolished by the guards’ humiliations, until they were left with nothing but an attitude of “everyone for himself”.
One particular episode seems emblematic. One of the prisoners went on hunger strike and was promptly put in solitary confinement by the guards. The guards then presented the other prisoners with a choice. If they gave up their blankets for the night, the man would be released. If they chose to keep their blankets, the man would stay in solitary all night.
The prisoners voted to keep their blankets.
Zimbardo calculated that about a third of the guards had become tyrannical, took pleasure in the power they wielded, and had also become very creative in finding ways to humiliate and further subjugate the prisoners. A majority of the guards were “normal” by prison standards. Another small group consisted of “good” guards who treated the prisoners humanely and occasionally did them favours. Of these Zimbardo wrote that yes, they were “good”, but they never interfered with the activities and commands of the “bad” guards, nor did they ever complain to him personally, acting as he was in the role of prison superintendent. The “good” guards, more than the “bad” ones, seemed to reinforce the reality of the prison: first because the fact that the other guards acted tyrannically served their need to be liked by others; second because their behaviour placed the prisoners in an ambiguous and uncertain zone in which rebellion became less likely.
The experiment began to take on a life of its own: “by the end of the week the experiment had become a reality, as if it were a Pirandello play directed by Kafka that simply kept going on even after the audience had left”, which is one of the reasons why Zimbardo decided to end the experiment, which lasted a total of six days.
Following the experiment, Zimbardo’s central thesis was that: “the mere act of assigning labels to people and putting them in a situation where those labels acquire validity and meaning is sufficient to elicit pathological behaviour that is not predictable from any existing diagnostic indicator.” In essence, the situation alone was a sufficient condition to produce aberrant and anti-social behaviour.
Follow-up
Longitudinal studies two years later revealed that the subjects continued to be within the norm and showed no pathology of any kind.
This finding further strengthens Zimbardo’s interpretation of the Stanford prison experiment regarding the force of social pressures and of circumstance on human behaviour.