{"id":2736,"date":"2016-09-30T07:34:53","date_gmt":"2016-09-30T05:34:53","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/2016\/09\/30\/what-do-scientists-really-think-about-meditation\/"},"modified":"2016-09-30T07:34:53","modified_gmt":"2016-09-30T05:34:53","slug":"what-do-scientists-really-think-about-meditation","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/2016\/09\/30\/what-do-scientists-really-think-about-meditation\/","title":{"rendered":"What do scientists really think about meditation?"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>I was recently pointed to an <strong><a href=\"http:\/\/www.salon.com\/2015\/07\/16\/scientists_meditated_on_meditation_%E2%80%93_and_the_results_were_troubling_partner\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">article published in Scientific American<\/a><\/strong> in which John Horgan, science journalist and author, summed up everything that, from a scientific point of view, is \u201cwrong\u201d with meditation. I found it interesting, but I also found that some clarifications were needed. With this article I hope to summarise Horgan\u2019s arguments and add my own personal criticisms and thoughts.<\/p>\n<p>I will briefly sum up the positions of the article. The author introduces himself by saying that he has often ventured into meditation, drawn from various traditions, and that he uses it mainly to relax. Lately, however, he writes, there are things about the practice that bother him, thoughts he cannot get rid of precisely while he is meditating. A sort of meditation on meditation.<\/p>\n<p>Horgan then identifies a number of points on which his irritation is focused:<\/p>\n<ol>\n<li>meditation has become a fad;<\/li>\n<li>those who do research on meditation also practise it;<\/li>\n<li>there is no convincing evidence that meditation is superior to other treatments;<\/li>\n<li>the beneficial effect of meditation would be down to the placebo effect;<\/li>\n<li>the changes meditation brings about in the brain do not necessarily imply a benefit to health or well-being;<\/li>\n<li>despite claims to the contrary, meditation does not produce good Samaritans: meditation is ethically neutral;<\/li>\n<li>those who set themselves up as gurus are often con men, fanatics or psychopaths;<\/li>\n<li>meditating takes up too much time, when one could be helping others;<\/li>\n<li>each meditator discovers a different, incontrovertible truth that conflicts with that of other practitioners;<\/li>\n<li>the claim of meditating without a goal is false: meditating without seeking a goal is a goal in itself.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p>Before going into the arguments of the article, a brief word about myself.<\/p>\n<p>I have a degree in <strong>psychology<\/strong>, and my thesis studied the possible effects of <strong>Mindfulness<\/strong> (a type of meditation) on chronic pain. Consequently, my knowledge of the scientific findings on meditation is limited to the field of Mindfulness and, within the vast sea that characterises it, I have specific knowledge of its effect on chronic pain. That said, my theoretical knowledge is complemented by a long-standing daily personal practice. My knowledge of meditation is therefore <strong>partial and specialised<\/strong>.<\/p>\n<p>For this reason, as you can imagine, I find it hard to give you a single definition of the word \u201cmeditation\u201d. From my point of view it is a very general term that gathers under itself an enormous variety of practices, traditions and philosophies, which have different assumptions and historical origins and refer to different cultural contexts. I could describe it as a river: the more general the term becomes, the closer it comes to its delta, where the single branches separate only to rejoin and separate again. This is why, among meditation practices, one can find points of contact with other traditions which may nonetheless be misunderstandings, or misleading, or similar but different when placed alongside other techniques complementary to a discipline. To give you at least a summary of what can be found out there, at least in relation to what is studied in science, the literature distinguishes, without trying to be exhaustive, three broad types of meditation technique: concentrative meditation, monitoring meditation and transcendental meditation.<\/p>\n<p><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" class=\"aligncenter size-medium wp-image-2270\" src=\"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/09\/compassion-meditation-672x372.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"672\" height=\"372\" srcset=\"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/09\/compassion-meditation-672x372.jpg 672w, https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/09\/compassion-meditation-672x372-300x166.jpg 300w, https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/09\/compassion-meditation-672x372-260x144.jpg 260w, https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/09\/compassion-meditation-672x372-50x28.jpg 50w, https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/09\/compassion-meditation-672x372-135x75.jpg 135w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 672px) 100vw, 672px\" \/><\/p>\n<ul>\n<li><strong>Concentrative meditation<\/strong> refers to the technique in which attention is focused on an object, commonly the breath, but it could also be a point in the body, an image, or the sound of a repeated word (as in a mantra). The aim of these techniques is to silence the chatter of the mind and, in some cases, any experience extraneous to the object, in the moment and for as long as concentration is maintained.<\/li>\n<li>In <strong>monitoring meditation<\/strong> the mind observes experience as it unfolds to consciousness. The aim of these techniques is to cultivate a non-reaction towards external and internal stimuli that would usually produce a reaction, which in turn results in automatic behaviour. In more advanced forms of these techniques the mind observes not only bodily experience but also itself as it observes, thus becoming the object of careful and very deep observation.<\/li>\n<li>In <strong>transcendental meditation<\/strong> one seeks to cultivate more ethical aspects, through the expression of compassion towards oneself and other living beings.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Few meditation traditions use only one \u201cpure\u201d type of technique as described above; it is more likely, in fact, to find a greater emphasis on some techniques rather than others. For example, in order to reach monitoring techniques, an earlier practice of concentrative techniques may be needed to allow the mind to remain more disciplined, instead of running off in all directions.<\/p>\n<p>Horgan\u2019s argument is more generic. It is addressed, in short, to everything that sits under this \u201cumbrella\u201d we call meditation. This is why I believe a clarification is all the more necessary.<\/p>\n<p>Let us now look at the single points of the article in more depth.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Hype Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Here we agree with the author. After initial <strong><a href=\"http:\/\/www.adrianostefani.it\/articolo-psicologia.php?id_art=54\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">wariness<\/a><\/strong> in the community of scientists and mental health professionals, research interest in meditation has grown exponentially in recent years. According to data published by PubMed, the search engine for scientific papers, from about 20 publications a year on meditation around the 1990s, we are today close to the threshold of 400 publications a year. Backed by this research, meditation has landed in the major newspapers and opinion magazines, as well as on television. In other words, <strong>meditation has become fashionable<\/strong>. On the one hand I find this a positive thing. It means there is a chance that more people will do something that can potentially benefit them. On the other hand, the excessive popularisation of meditation can make something seem easy when it is not. <strong>For those who set out on the path, meditation is, and remains, a hard, constant and demanding discipline.<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><strong>The Allegiance Effect Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Here we partly agree with the author. Those who study a particular meditation technique, be it Transcendental Meditation, Zazen or the pranic meditation of yoga, <strong>practise<\/strong> it. This, as the author rightly says, can lead to distortions in the judgement of those who study meditation, a sort of \u201cconflict of interest\u201d. On the other hand, I would note, those who practise a given technique have a greater knowledge of the technique itself and can therefore study it more incisively. This is relevant because the technique and the philosophy underlying each form of meditation can be extremely complex and easily misunderstood. The assumption the author makes in this part of the article is that one can do research \u201cobjectively\u201d, that is, that the researcher can subject an observed phenomenon to scientific scrutiny without the researcher\u2019s own characteristics influencing the observation.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Dodo Bird Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>The author of the article refers to a <strong><a href=\"http:\/\/effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov\/ehc\/products\/375\/1830\/Meditation-report-140106.pdf\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">review by the Johns Hopkins University Evidence-Based Practice Center<\/a><\/strong> in which, of about 17,000 papers examined, only 41 are considered high-quality studies, for a population of about 3,000 subjects. The review finds that meditation produces a moderate effect on pain, and a low-to-moderate effect on anxiety, depression and stress. Moreover, the benefits were not found to be superior to any of the specific therapies with which these meditation techniques were compared. These specific therapies include physical exercise, muscle relaxation and cognitive behavioural therapy. In short, we do not know how effective or ineffective these techniques are compared with one another. From my point of view, if this were true, I would weigh up <strong>the advantages meditation offers over these specific therapies<\/strong>. For example, meditation involves relatively little expense in monetary terms (think of the cost of a gym or physiotherapy sessions), requires no special equipment (such as TENS for muscle relaxation), and encourages people to gather in meditation groups, or sanghas (think instead of the strictly one-to-one relationship between psychotherapist and patient in cognitive behavioural therapy). As for the <strong>disadvantages I can report about meditation<\/strong>, these are certainly the time it requires, the negative sensations that may be experienced at least at the beginning, and the stress that may temporarily increase rather than decrease.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Placebo Effect Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>According to the author, because in meditation one holds an expectation of feeling well, in the end one will feel well. A sort of <strong>self-fulfilling prophecy<\/strong>. Or the effect of so-called <strong>semantic priming<\/strong>, whereby it is enough to write a series of words on a sheet of paper, or repeat them as in a mantra (take synonyms of \u201chappy\u201d, for example), to begin to feel happy! This effect operates outside the awareness of the people influenced by it. Or, again, an expression of the <strong>placebo effect<\/strong>, whereby simply doing something for a purpose, such as a medical treatment, can have positive consequences (or negative ones, in the case of the nocebo effect) on the patient\u2019s general health. The argument put forward here, however, seems weak to me, first of all because it hides <strong>neo-Cartesian<\/strong> assumptions that would have a sharp division between body and mind. If the argument is that meditation is only a placebo effect, what is being said is that there is an effect that depends only on the person\u2019s mental states and not a \u201creal\u201d, more objective and physical cure. Drug studies themselves take into account and make use of the placebo effect (to which sensitivity varies from person to person), so if one effect of meditation can be greater well-being, and this well-being were \u201call\u201d placebo, what would be the problem? Would the goal not have been reached anyway?<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Brain Scan Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>We fully agree with the author on this point. <strong>Thanks to brain plasticity, any prolonged activity, think of tennis, can produce changes in the volume of grey matter in this or that area of the brain.<\/strong> Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies of the brain changes produced by the activity of meditation, that is the increase in volume of certain areas compared with others, do not necessarily imply a causal link between meditation and well-being or the improvement of other mental abilities.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Niceness Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>According to the author, meditation is an ethically neutral activity, like going for a run. It therefore does not produce \u201cbetter\u201d or \u201ckinder\u201d people, as is instead claimed in certain contexts where meditation is taught. The example he gives is that meditation is part of many martial arts, arts that were the preserve of a warrior caste whose end product was not roses and daisies but the destruction of the enemy. Today there is a type of Mindfulness, Mindfulness-Based Fitness Training (MBFT), which is being taught within the United States armed forces to increase soldiers\u2019 resilience to the harshness of combat; think of the post-traumatic stress disorder that afflicts veterans of modern warfare. Here, in my view, the author does the reader a disservice. Meditation is, in the end, an umbrella term that gathers under itself an enormous variety of different traditions, philosophies and techniques. While concentrative meditations, where one seeks a state of deep silence from the \u201cchatter\u201d of the mind, and monitoring meditations, where one seeks to study the mind as it presents itself in the observation of experience, may fit the author\u2019s description, loving-kindness meditation (Metta), in which one wishes all beings to be happy and free from suffering, has deep ethical implications. Some authors within the scientific community also ask <strong><a href=\"http:\/\/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/pubmed\/21254062\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">how much sense it makes to extract meditation techniques from the philosophical and moral context that created them<\/a><\/strong>, an operation that, incidentally, has been carried out in Mindfulness. Not by chance, it has been argued that a definition of meditation as \u201cpaying attention intentionally, moment by moment, non-judgementally\u201d describes a state of mind that the meditator may well have, but so may the sniper about to shoot his human target. This is why the teaching of meditation is complemented by the development of compassion, that is a concern for the suffering of others combined with the wish to relieve it, and by the development of wisdom, that is the understanding of one\u2019s own and others\u2019 suffering. To imply that meditation is an ethically neutral activity is to deny that compassion and wisdom, as I have defined them here, are also part of the context in which meditation is taught: qualities of mind closely linked to each other which, as <strong><a href=\"http:\/\/bigthink.com\/videos\/paul-ekman-on-global-compassion\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Paul Ekman\u2019s recent research<\/a><\/strong> indicates, can be cultivated and are not necessarily innate in human beings.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Bad Guru Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>I agree with the author on this point. Most of the successful spiritual gurus who have arrived in the West are ambiguous figures, con men at best, narcissistic psychopaths at worst. In his book <strong><a href=\"http:\/\/www.amazon.it\/Waking-Up-Spirituality-Without-Religion-ebook\/dp\/B00GEEB9YC\/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1438350679&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=sam+harris\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">Waking Up<\/a><\/strong>, which I recommend to anyone wishing to devote themselves seriously to meditation, Sam Harris discusses at length the qualities a guru should have, what a guru may ask of their disciples, where to set boundaries and how to protect oneself. Guidelines with which I agree. Here, unfortunately, there is a dilemma. <strong>Those who set out on the path must cultivate a deep balance between their critical sense and the trust to be placed in their teacher.<\/strong> Our critical sense must guide us at every moment of the journey, knowing that it may be precisely this that prevents us from truly learning. That said, even though having a teacher is a necessity for anyone who seriously takes up the path, one must know how to protect oneself, because the abuses, or the financial losses, that can be suffered by following a \u201cbad\u201d guru should never be underestimated.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Matthieu Ricard Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>Here the author finds it paradoxical that one should meditate on compassion in order to reach a state of deep mental peace. He also wonders why so much time should be spent producing this state, when it could be better used to help others. Personally I do not find the first point paradoxical. The aim of most meditation techniques is to activate a part of the mind that sees the world as a whole. Within this enlarged world there are we ourselves, together with all the extraordinary things that inhabit it. We therefore cease to be the sole centre of our world; indeed, concern for ourselves is replaced by a broader concern for others, our fellow humans as well as non-human animals. This form of deindividuation, far from being pathological, produces a deep sense of peace, joy, compassion and interest in the well-being of others. It is, however, a state of the mind (and of the brain) that must be cultivated and that requires prolonged, constant practice before it expresses itself. A boundless sense of love obtainable temporarily, if anything in excess, by other means (think of MDMA, also known as \u201cecstasy\u201d, or of deep brain stimulation). The fact that it takes time to attain this sense of universal love, not unlike that felt by some saints of the Christian tradition and treated here merely as another potential the human mind can reach, serves to ensure that the act of helping others is not contaminated by a mind that thinks of its own well-being before that of others. In this second case, the act of helping others may have quite a different meaning, personal gratification for instance, something that would fall outside an action moved by a true sense of compassion.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Truth Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>According to the author, for some practitioners the aim of meditation is knowledge. The problem is, as he rightly writes, that each meditator finds a different truth, often in conflict with the truth of other practitioners. Here again we meet the problem of using the single word \u201cmeditation\u201d to describe a variety of different practices. In Mindfulness, for example, the aim of meditation is simply to be aware of what is happening, as it happens. That said, I recognise meditation as a powerful tool for knowledge of, and contact with, one\u2019s own present reality. Such knowledge is in no way to be considered academic knowledge, and it is valid only for the moment in which it is experienced. For Vipassana, another popular form of meditation from which Mindfulness has borrowed a great deal, such knowledge is a \u201cseeing clearly\u201d of the state we are in at the moment we observe ourselves, that is, making intimate contact with the essence of what it means to be human.<\/p>\n<p><strong>The Having No Goal Problem<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>The author cannot understand how, for some meditators, there could really be no purpose in meditating. Meditation is a practice that is an end in itself. His comment, though, is that having no goal is a goal! Whoever claims to have no goal only confirms to him that meditation is a sort of self-brainwashing. From my point of view, and in relation to what I know in particular about hemispheric specialisation, what meditation seeks to evoke is a state of being whose activation tends to be discrete and alternative to the ordering structures of the mind (the so-called executive functions). Such a state has no ordered goals, does not judge experience, and operates in parallel rather than sequentially. The paradox the author sees ought to provoke the laughter of the gods; contemplating it could make his meditation even deeper, and could give him insights into the condition of experience in which we all find ourselves.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Conclusions<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>At the end of this long post I can only thank the author for giving me the opportunity to stop and take stock of my knowledge of meditation, knowledge I did not know I had until it became relevant to the argument I have tried to make here. Meditation is an umbrella term; beneath it lies an enormous variety of practices, a thousand-year history of traditions, a technology of the self available to us today for experimenting with the boundaries of our consciousness, while we find the extraordinary in our ordinary experience. Distinctions are necessary; otherwise, like the author, one ends up hating meditation while practising it. This too is a paradox in which the laughter of the gods can be heard in the distance, and which tells us, at every moment, who we really are.<\/p>\n<p><em>* article also published on <a href=\"https:\/\/bottadiclasse.wordpress.com\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">bottadiclasse<\/a><\/em><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>I was recently pointed to an article published in Scientific American in which John Horgan, science journalist and author, summed up everything that, from a scientific point of\u2026<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":2278,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[103,104],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-2736","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-meditation-en","category-psychotechniques-en"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2736","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=2736"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2736\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/2278"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=2736"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=2736"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/dottorpirropsicologo.it\/en\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=2736"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}